Why You Should Never Close Your First Credit Card

  • Home
  • Articles
  • Why You Should Never Close Your First Credit Card
shape shape
image

Let’s talk about your oldest credit card. You know, that one you got way back when. Maybe it’s tucked in a drawer somewhere. Your first thought might be to close it, especially if you have newer, shinier cards with better perks. But here’s the deal: closing that old card can actually hurt your credit score. And since you’re working on building great credit, that’s the last thing you want.

Think of your credit history like a long, trustworthy friendship. The longer you’ve known someone, the more others can see that you’re a reliable friend. Your credit score loves to see long friendships. That oldest credit card is your longest financial friendship. When you close the account, it’s like erasing those years of good history. The credit bureaus can’t see that long friendship anymore, and that can make your score drop.

Another big reason is something called your credit utilization. That’s just a fancy way of saying how much of your available credit you’re using. Let’s say you have two cards. Your old card has a $1,000 limit, and your new card has a $1,000 limit. That means you have $2,000 total credit you could use. If you have a $500 balance, you’re only using a small part of your available credit, which is good. But if you close the old card, suddenly you only have $1,000 in total credit. That same $500 balance now uses up half of your available credit, which looks risky to lenders. Keeping the old card open helps keep that total available credit number nice and high.

So, what should you do with this old card? You don’t have to use it for everything. The key is to keep it alive and active. A simple trick is to use it for one small, regular thing. Maybe you buy one coffee a month with it, or use it to pay for a streaming service. Then, set up automatic payments so the full balance is paid off from your bank account every single month. This shows the card company you’re still using the account, and it keeps that valuable history growing longer every month.

Just make sure the card doesn’t have a big annual fee that you’re paying for no reason. If it does, you can sometimes call the company and ask them to change it to a card with no fee. They’d rather keep you as a customer than lose you completely.

In the end, your oldest credit card is a powerful tool for your credit history. It’s proof of your long-term responsibility. By keeping it open and using it wisely, even in a very small way, you’re telling the whole credit world that you are a dependable person. You are building a strong, long-lasting financial foundation, and that oldest card is a cornerstone of it. So dig it out, give it a little job to do, and let it keep helping you build a fantastic credit future.

  • What to Do If You Miss a Payment ·
  • Understand Your Card's Terms and Fees ·
  • Use Calendar Alerts for Your Due Dates ·
  • Ask to Be a Credit Card Authorized User ·
  • What Makes Your Score Go Down? ·
  • Build Credit Without a Credit Card ·


FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Your oldest card is special because it shows how long you’ve been responsible with credit. Think of it like a long-term friendship—the longer it lasts, the stronger it looks. Credit bureaus love to see a long history. Closing that account can make your overall credit history look shorter instantly. This can cause your credit score to drop. It’s the anchor of your credit history, so keep it safely open even if you don’t use it much.

You can use valuable items you own that the lender can accept. The most common things are cash (like a savings account or certificate of deposit), your car, or sometimes the equity in your home. The item must be worth enough to cover the loan amount. For building credit, a “savings-secured loan,“ where you borrow against your own money in the bank, is often the safest and easiest place to start.

The rules are usually simpler than for a regular loan. You typically need to be a member of the credit union (which is easy to join), have a steady source of income, and be able to afford the monthly payments. They often don’t check your existing credit score heavily, because the whole point is to help you build it. The main thing they want to see is that you are reliable and can make those small payments each month.

You should check it about once a month. Checking your own score through your bank does NOT hurt it—that’s a myth! A monthly check lets you see if your good habits are paying off. It also helps you catch mistakes or fraud quickly. Think of it like a monthly health check-up for your finances. Just set a reminder on your phone to log in and take a quick look. It only takes a minute.

Missing a payment is one of the worst things you can do for your credit with a car loan. Even one late payment can seriously hurt your score and will stay on your credit report for seven years. The lender may also charge you late fees. It tells future lenders that you might not be reliable. Always set up reminders or automatic payments to make sure you never miss a due date.